• FAIL Blog
  • Employee
  • Workplace
  • Horrible Bosses
  • Neighbors
  • HOA
  • Family Drama
  • Parenting
  • Customer Service
  • Entitled People

  • Links
  • About Us
  • Editorial Guidelines
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Security
  • DMCA Policy
    • search email community favorite this article chev-right latest posts article list comments tags video article login twitter facebook menu pinterest whatsapp

    Roommate’s girlfriend moves in without paying rent, sparkling debate about bills and household boundaries: 'I never agreed to a third roommate'

    Most roommates understand that relationships come with sleepovers, shared dinners, and the occasional extra toothbrush in the bathroom. But when a guest starts functioning like a full-time resident, boundaries and expectations matter. 

    This tenant didn't mind his roommate's girlfriend staying over at first. The issue only started when occasional visits became constant presence, using utilities, taking up space, and effectively becoming a third person in a two-person lease. At that point, it may be less about drama and more about fairness.

    Like what you see? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google. 

    Author image for Inés Soubrie Inés Soubrie
    Add as a preferred
    source on Google
    Advertisement
    • 01
      Woman is cooking while her roommate hang out in the kitchen with her.
      via Unsplash (and A. C.)

      Woman is cooking while her roommate hang out in the kitchen with her. 

      Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    • Advertisement

    • Most people would agree that having a partner over now and then is part of shared living. Sleepovers happen. Extra dinners happen. Someone may use the shower, borrow a charger, or leave a hoodie behind. That usually comes with the territory.

      And in most cases, no one expects rent for that.

      But there’s a difference between visiting and moving in slowly enough that everyone is expected not to notice.

    • 02
      So I live with a roommate and we split rent 50/50. Everything was fine at first. Then he got a girlfriend. At first she would just stay over sometimes, which was totally fine.
      via Irynadream
    • 03
      But over time it turned into her basically living here. She sleeps here, eats our food, uses the shower, the washing machine, leaves her stuff all over the apartment.
      via Irynadream

    • That seems to be the real issue here.

      According to this tenant, what began as occasional stays gradually turned into something much bigger. The roommate’s girlfriend was sleeping there regularly, eating shared food, using the washing machine, leaving belongings around the apartment, and even being there alone when no one else was home.

    • 04
      Woman in sweatshirts looking for food in the fridge at night.
      via Unsplash (and Sydney Moore)

      Woman in sweatshirts looking for food in the fridge at night. 

      Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    • Advertisement
    • 05
      Sometimes I come home and she's just there alone like it's her place.
      via Irynadream

    • At a certain point, that stops feeling like a guest arrangement.

      It starts feeling like a third roommate, except only two people are paying.

      That frustration is understandable. Shared housing works best when everyone agrees on expectations. If one person suddenly changes the living dynamic without a real conversation, the other person is left absorbing the cost, the space shift, and the discomfort of raising the issue later.

    • 06
      Casually dressed woman lays down in the couch while reading.
      via Unsplash (and Giorgio Trovato)

      Casually dressed woman lays down in the couch while reading. 

      Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    • Advertisement
    • 07
      I kept quiet because I didn't want to start drama. But at some point I realized I'm paying for half the apartment while basically living with two people.
      via Irynadream
    • 08
      I talked to my roommate and said this isn't okay either she starts contributing or she shouldn't be here all the time. He brushed it off,
      via Irynadream
    • Advertisement
    • 09
      saying things like she just stays over a lot and you're overreacting.
      via Irynadream

    • And to be fair, this probably doesn’t need to be treated like a villain story.

      It’s possible the couple simply got comfortable and didn’t realize how much the arrangement had changed. That happens. Sometimes people slide into routines without noticing how it affects others.

      But once it was brought up, it deserved to be taken seriously.

    • 10
      Sad and frustrated woman sits in a couch.
      via Unsplash (and Blake Cheek)

      Sad and frustrated woman sits in a couch. 

      Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    • The healthiest next step here likely isn’t more tension, it’s a real conversation. If she’s going to be there most days, then clearer boundaries or some kind of contribution may be reasonable. That could mean helping with rent, utilities, groceries, or agreeing on limits around overnight stays.

    • 11
      the other day I told her directly that she doesn't live here and needs to stop coming over every day. She
      via Irynadream
    • Advertisement
    • 12
      got upset, he got mad, and now the apartment is tense and they both think I'm the ah le. But I never agreed
      via Irynadream
    • 13
      Roommates discussing in the couch casually dressed.
      via Unsplash (and Getty Images)

      Roommates discussing in the couch casually dressed. 

      Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    • 14
      to a third roommate. AITA for setting boundaries instead of just putting up with it?
      via Irynadream
    • Advertisement

    • Because relationships growing is normal. So is respecting the people you live with.

      No one needs to be the bad guy for this to be solvable. Sometimes fairness just needs to be named out loud before everyone can move forward comfortably.

       

    • 15
      angelkry NTA of course, thats being inconsiderate.
      via angelkry
    • 16
      rvnesSV NTA, If she's using your utilities like it's her own, she should be contributing to the maintenance, cleaning and buying her own food. You shouldn't be playing for a 3rd person.
      via rvnesSV
    • 17
      junkiiiii NTA - I'm going to be honest. I did this with my gf in my 20's and I didn't realize why my gf's friend was so upset over it. I was being a complete selfish You have every right to be upset and you should not be put in this situation.
      via junkiiiii
    • Advertisement
    • 18
      Idkwhy8154 NTA. I've fantasized about being the kind of person who would actually say this kind of thing out loud. Bravo! They are the a_h_les! They should get their own place or hang out at hers more.
      via Idkwhy8154
    • 19
      Loud_Shallot_1367 NTA. Contact your landlord and have the rules explained to your roommate. Either she pays 1/3 of the expenses or she stays the agreed amount of nights only
      via Loud_Shallot_1367
    • 20
      ModeratelyOffline NTA. It's one thing for a partner to be hanging out, but eating your food and leaving things everywhere is unacceptable. I agree with those saying to check your lease, some have guest policies.
      via ModeratelyOffline
    • Advertisement
    • 21
      Buckleupbutterc... NTA. Tell him one more time that she is not allowed to be there 24/7 and if he doesn't comply talk to the landlord. She's not on the lease.
      via Buckleupbuttercup77
    • 22
      arina 1945 NTA. If she wants to be there all the time, she needs to contribute with the money too. Because not only she's practically living there, but she's also using more power, water, gas, etc for her needs, and it's not fair that you're paying for her share too.
      via arina1945
    • 23
      corenthil_53 yeah I'm on your side heavy. like it's not even about her personally, it's about boundaries and fairness. utilities, space, food. those aren't magically free just bc she's his gf ppl love avoiding "drama" until someone finally speaks up, then suddenly YOU'RE the problem. nah, you just said what should've been said weeks ago tbh.
      via Corenthil_53
    • Advertisement
    • 24
      Either-Cover-6667 NTA. She needs to contribute to rent or leave.
      via Either-Cover-6677
    • 25
      rojita369 NTA. Time to talk to the landlord. Let them know a third person has moved in.
      via Rojita369
    • 26
      Mammoth_Shoul... NTA - next time, set your boundaries at the beginning of your lease so things like this doesn't happen. Having a simple signed agreement amongst you and a roommate will do wonders.
      via Mammoth_Shoulder_816
    • Advertisement
    • 27
      Comprehensive Ti... Tell them both,if she doesn't start paying you back what she's eaten and used and doesn't start paying 1/3 of every, you will tell the landlord because youve been financing this woman for how long now!!!?????
      via ComprehensiveTill411
    • 28
      voxetpraetereani... NTA. Had a roommate like this once basically moved her - boyfriend in, despite my straight up saying I wasn't comfortable with it. When it came time to renew our lease, she was surprised I decided not to stay. He was unemployed, and she couldn't afford the place on her own, so kinda sucked for her I guess. But we were acquaintances not friends, so it was no loss to me.
      via voxetpraetereanihill
    • 29
      neon_crone Yeah, she's a roommate you didn't ask for, who is a freeloader. Does she even have another apartment? You've now learned the hard way to discuss these issues at the beginning. Setting limits like she can't be there when he's not there. How many nights a week she stays over.
      via neon_crone
    • Advertisement
    • 30
      Hpobjoy I would tell your room mate that you would only pay a third of the bills INCLUDING rent as why should you subsidize her living expenses. It would be interesting to hear his reaction. If he didn't agree. I would then tell the landlord that there is an unauthorised person staying at the apartment.
      via Hpobjoy
    • 31
      Prechrchet NTA: Notify your landlord that a third person has moved in, over and above your objections.
      via Prechrchet
    • 32
      OniyaMCD NTA - find a copy of your lease and look for the section on 'subletting' or 'guest policy'. Show it to your roommate. If her lengthy stay a) violates that section of the lease and b) the landlord finds out (like from a neighbor in the building), then all three of you will be out on your
      via OniyaMCD

    Like what you see? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google. 

    Tags

    bad roommates reddit story Reddit roommates money entitled people
    Like
    Scroll Down For The Next Article
    Show Comments

    Also From FAIL Blog

    Dad protects his peace by DIYing noise-canceling bumpers on the kitchen cabinets when his family refuses to respect his rule to stop slamming the doors: ‘I hate loud noises’

    Dad protects his peace by DIYing noise-canceling bumpers on the kitchen cabinets when his family refuses to respect his rule to stop slamming the doors: ‘I hate loud noises’
    Next Article