• FAIL Blog
  • Employee
  • Workplace
  • Horrible Bosses
  • Neighbors
  • HOA
  • Family Drama
  • Parenting
  • Customer Service
  • Entitled People

  • Links
  • About Us
  • Editorial Guidelines
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Security
  • DMCA Policy
    • search email community favorite this article chev-right latest posts article list comments tags video article login twitter facebook menu pinterest whatsapp

    Fired employee wins $17K after former law firm employer refuses to pay his earned commissions: ‘They thought they could rip me off $4k and turned into substantially more’

    There's something poetic in watching a law firm lose a legal fight it started by being smug. Nothing levels the field faster than arrogance meeting paperwork In this case, one man's unpaid commission became a slow-burning revenge story powered by nothing more than patience and receipts

    Like what you see? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google. 

    Author image for Etai Eshet Etai Eshet
    Add as a preferred
    source on Google
    Advertisement
    • Smiling businessman wearing glasses and a light blue button-down shirt standing by a glass railing inside a modern office building, looking to the side.
      via Getty Images For Unsplash+

      Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    • Advertisement

    • Old employer F'd around and found out.

      Little back story: I was hired at a law firm beginning of last year, I was by far their top sales person but was terminated because my female boss had an issue with men.
      via ThatWideLife
    • They had the bright idea to not pay out all earned commissions I was owed and severed all communications.
      via ThatWideLife
    • I was owed what I thought was roughly $4k but was under estimating it. They could've paid what I thought I was owed and it would've been done with.
      via ThatWideLife
    • Advertisement
    • So within a few weeks of being terminated I filed an unpaid wage claim with the Department of Labor.
      via ThatWideLife

    • The story starts at a law firm where the employee quickly becomes the top salesperson. Numbers speak louder than hierarchy, and apparently that didn’t sit well with the boss, who decides to cut him loose. To make things worse, the firm refuses to pay out his earned commissions, worth about four thousand by his estimate. They stop answering his messages, figuring he’ll give up. Instead, he files a claim with the Department of Labor, which is basically the workplace version of pressing the big red button. 

    • It was a very slow process that took nearly a year to conclude. The Department of Labor calculated they actually owed me $6,700 and issued a demand for them to pay me December of 2025.
      via ThatWideLife
    • Advertisement
    • The employer stood their ground stating they didn't owe me and refused to pay the amount requested.
      via ThatWideLife
    • Smiling businessman wearing glasses and a button-down shirt talking on a smartphone while leaning on a railing inside a modern office building with large windows.
      via Getty Images For Unsplash+

      Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    • Advertisement
    • Fast forward to now, the Department of Labor found them guilty of willful wage theft and now they owe me close to $17k due in 14 days, no appeal.
      via ThatWideLife

    • Time ticks on, months stretch into nearly a year, and finally the department finishes its review. Turns out the firm didn’t owe four grand, it owed sixty‑seven hundred, and officials demand payment. The firm responds with the kind of confidence only people drenched in legal certificates can have, they refuse. That’s when everything flips. The Department finds them guilty of willful wage theft and doubles down with penalties, fines, and interest until the total hits seventeen thousand, due in two weeks with no appeal.  

    • These geniuses admitted to doing clawbacks on full and partial refunds despite me never agreeing to it.
      via ThatWideLife
    • My compensation agreement stated clearly all commissions are earned once payments are made to them. So not only were they found guilty of wage theft, they were guilty of violating multiple wage laws in my state.
      via ThatWideLife
    • Advertisement
    • Thought I would share because I find it hysterical. They thought they could rip me off $4k and turned into substantially more once people looked into it.
      via ThatWideLife

    • The best part if you ask me is how they confessed mid‑process, admitting to doing “clawbacks” on commissions that were clearly earned, a move their own written contract forbade. In other words, they lawyered themselves into a corner. What started as petty vindictiveness ended as an expensive lesson in labor law.  

    • Because they were a law firm they truly believed they were untouchable. I beat the entire firm by myself with no attorney.
      via ThatWideLife
    • Always keep records of everything, never know when you'll need it. You lose access to everything with no warning when terminated so always protect yourself from an employer.
      via ThatWideLife
    • Advertisement

    • It’s rare to watch justice play out this neatly, especially against a firm that believed rules were optional. The takeaway here isn’t just about winning, it’s about keeping records. Every email, every receipt, every line item, those are quiet tools of self‑defense. The law firm thought it was untouchable. Turns out, no one is bulletproof when the paper trail is perfectly documented.

    • I had every single transaction they made during my employment there which is ultimately what won the case.
      via ThatWideLife
    • III_Stick_Around It wasn't clear from your post, but did you actually get paid? If not, what happens when the 14 days are up? Do you have to get an attorney to collect?
      via ThatWideLife
    • ThatWideLife Original Poster's Reply No, they have yet to which term they are paying. If no payment is made in 14 days he owes me close to $30k and nearly $5k in fines to Department of Labor. If he doesn't pay in 60 days owes me close to $40k. Failure to pay at all results in garnishments and liens. This would be done at a state level, I don't need to do anything. Honestly, I kinda hope they are stupid and don't pay. They will owe me a substantial amount of money and all attorney fees would be p
      via ThatWideLife
    • Advertisement
    • Swiggy1957 I'm thinking that the DOL might consider filing a complaint with the state Bar Association. Imagine any cases they already have coming to a screeching halt if all of their licenses are suspended/disbarred. Where I live, practicing law without a license can land them 180 days in jail and up to $1,000 fine per incident. Note, IANAL, but this is the first thing that comes to mind.
      via ThatWideLife
    • Secretagentman94 Yes, I love hearing of things like this! Do not put up with greedy corporate bulls !
      via ThatWideLife
    • ThatWideLife Original Poster's Reply It was a saga to put it mildly. I thought for sure I would lose because we all know how much people side with employers. So glad it's a final F you to them lol. I warned them of the laws they were breaking and they ghosted me.
      via ThatWideLife
    • Advertisement
    • rxspiir My dad went through this. Claim ended at 72k from a measly 8k they owed him once he was fired. Was an engineering firm. They took their sweet time because I guess they thought being a multi million dollar firm with some minor connections to the state would mean something to the DoL. It was clear as day on paper that they didn't pay his final check or any PTO (which was in the contract). It got so large because of attorney fees as OP stated. Some of these places act above the law for so l
      via ThatWideLife
    • ThatWideLife Original Poster's Reply D in, now that's a really high oops penalty. You really have to give it to the Department of Labor, one of the few government agencies that actually seems to care about the little guy. I was skeptical at first, they didn't seem to take it seriously at first and it dragged on so long. I almost gave up at first. I had so much resistance with finding an attorney to handle it. I swear, the second they heard I worked for a law firm they literally said "Sorry not f
      via ThatWideLife
    • Wonderer23 I think jerks like this should get a felony on their record, and jail time. Some poor person steals a loaf of bread, and that's what he gets.
      via ThatWideLife
    • Advertisement
    • ThatWideLife Original Poster's Reply Well its not over yet. Once they actually pay me the next step is reporting them to the BAR. What he did is a violation of their ethics so odds are very high they will suspend his license or revoke it entirely. Funny thing is, he already had his license suspended for 2 years prior for unethical practice and dishonesty. Strike 2 gonna hit much harder I'm sure.
      via ThatWideLife
    • pmbpro Also the fact that it was a (gasp!) LAW FIRM, makes it all the sweeter, in my opinion. Congrats. OP!
      via ThatWideLife
    • ThatWideLife Original Poster's Reply Right? Very hard to claim a simple accounting error when they legally know the law lol. I warned them about other stuff they were doing prior to termination and they said I was wrong. Lawyers are arrogant, how dare some sales person state case law to them lol.
      via ThatWideLife
    • Advertisement
    • GrumpyOldMan59 Could you explain what constitutes sales at a law firm?
      via ThatWideLife
    • ThatWideLife Original Poster's Reply I onboarded potential new clients into paid clients. I handled everything besides the initial intake. Once they paid my role was done since legally I could no longer speak with them due to attorney/client privilege.
      via ThatWideLife
    • Worth_Mark7011 At this stage it's basically FAFO. Willful wage theft isn't a slap on the wrist. If they ignore it, liens plus garnishments hit and attorney fees shift to them. All over commissions they should've just paid.
      via ThatWideLife
    • Advertisement
    • ThatWideLife Original Poster's Reply Agreed, they already more than doubled the amount by taking a position of being right. By all means, let them not pay in 14 days, another $11k to me. The biggest part of my battle was trying to prove it was wilful which is hard to prove. I wish I could publish their responses and just how dumb they were. The CFO literally admitted they stole money from me and then in the same breath said they didn't. This was part of the reasons behind it being wilful. Best p
      via ThatWideLife
    • Mtndrums And the bar association of the state he's actually barred in.
      via ThatWideLife
    • ThatWideLife Original Poster's Reply Not barred, was suspended a few years back. He closed his firm for 2 years but back up and running.
      via ThatWideLife
    • Advertisement
    • crit_boy You dont need to wait to report conduct to the state bar. You could have already done it. Now with a judgment is better. But, call the state bar association on monday and ask what you need to do to file an official complaint. IAL, just not yours.
      via ThatWideLife
    • ThatWideLife Original Poster's Reply More so, would be real bad if they suspend him without getting paid first. Plus, need them to pay to admit guilt first, helps strengthen it.
      via ThatWideLife

    Like what you see? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google. 

    Tags

    management workplace discussion employment issues boss workplace-stories hr
    Like
    Scroll Down For The Next Article
    Show Comments

    Also From FAIL Blog

    New Jersey man wins a storage auction and sells valuable antiques, then the former tenant later demands them back, leaving him questioning ownership and responsibility

    New Jersey man wins a storage auction and sells valuable antiques, then the former tenant later demands them back, leaving him questioning ownership and responsibility
    Next Article