31 Hilarious Pop Culture Mashup Memes for the Ultimate Fans

There's a time-honored tradition among nerds, geeks, and anyone who's ever argued passionately about fictional characters like it was a matter of national security: the "Who Would Win?" debate. You've been there. Maybe you still are there. Goku vs. Superman. Batman vs. John Wick. Pikachu vs. Obi-Wan Kenobi. It's completely unhinged, wildly inconsistent, and the only rule is that there are no rules — just vibes, stubborn opinions, and way too many YouTube breakdowns.

The best part? Nobody ever agrees. There's no official scoreboard, no canon answer, and certainly no peace treaty. Just endless chaos, fueled by Reddit threads and caffeine. And yes, we all know Stan Lee's famous quote: "Who wins? Whoever the writer wants to win." Which is technically true… and also completely beside the point.

Because the whole fun is pretending it does matter. That Batman's prep time is a real superpower. That Doctor Who could out-weird Thanos into submission. That Aragorn with a lightsaber would absolutely wreck shop.

So, no — there are no definitive winners here. Just gloriously nerdy arguments and the memes that keep them going. Here are 32 of our favorites. May the best fictional fighter win. Or not.