'How would you feel if I gave you a gift, and then the same gift to another man?': Wife gets upset with husband for buying her and sister the same gift, internet is divided

The internet is divided over an argument this couple got into. The OP's husband bought her a gift she's been wanting for a while. However, her excitement was ruined when she found out that he had also bought the same gift for her sister. In her eyes, the gift was no longer special or thoughtful. Her husband apologized, but he didn't think that her reaction was justified, so the OP turned to the internet to ask whether she was valid to be upset.

Well, the internet is divided too. While some people understand that the wife wanted the gift to be meaningful to her, others feel that this case might be an exception. The gift was random, as it wasn't for a special occasion, and it wasn't particularly romantic. Some men in the comments section even suggested that the husband probably thought the gift was really cool, so why wouldn't he purchase it for both of them? I can understand this perspective because my partner thinks in the same way. However, perhaps the OP's love language is gift-giving, which warranted her hurt reaction. What do you think?